Are we to believe this is the face Park Shi Hoo made when he heard about the accusation? |
I’ve
thought a lot about whether I should write about the Park Shi Hoo
news.
Surfers
of dramaweb almost certainly already know more about this situation
than they want to. But for those of us lucky enough to have missed
the coverage, here’s a quick recap of every single piece of wholly
trustworthy information that’s now available: last month,
actor Park Shi Hoo was accused of rape after a night out with an
entertainment-industry friend and a girl he knew.
As
far as I can tell, beyond that it’s all hearsay and speculation.
I’ve been keeping an eye on the big English-language news sites and
their coverage of the story, and for every article touting some new
piece of information about the case I can find two other articles
that disprove everything it says.
I
can’t even critically assess these conflicting reports: I have
essentially no familiarity with the various Korean news outlets. If
similar charges were leveled against an American star, I would have a
better sense what was spurious and what deserved further
consideration. No news outlet in the world is infallible, but
when the New York Times reports
something, I feel safe trusting them to get the facts right and
present them in a reasonably objective manner. On the other hand, I
wouldn’t even bother reading coverage of the same incident in Star
magazine, a notorious
supermarket tabloid. A lifetime spent consuming American news and
culture has prepared me to understand the distinction between these
sources. But Naver? Hankyung? Chosunilbo? I have literally no idea
what their bent is or how trustworthy they might be.
And
as someone who speaks only English, I’m at an even further remove
the coverage. Relying on news that has been filtered through the
English-language aggregators isn’t the best idea when it comes
to actually understanding what’s going on.
Take
Drama Fever’s blog. I’ve been reading it regularly
ever since I first signed up as a member. Over that time its tone
has changed considerably. In early 2011, it focused on posting news
tidbits gleaned from sites like Dramabeans or Soompi. Later, it
specialized in guest boggers. But since its infusion of venture
capital money last fall, the Drama Fever blog has evolved into
something of a supermarket tabloid of its own. And I’m not going to
lie: I like its hodgepodge approach to celebrity gossip. I’ll
happily watch videos of Korean cats getting their butts scratched,
ogle photo galleries of handsome actors posted on their birthdays,
and devour speculation about whether some girl group member I’ve
never heard of is dating some boy group member I’ve never heard of.
The
problem is that Drama Fever misinterpreted the significance of this
story. Because it involves an actor, it is celebrity gossip. But
we’re not talking about whether his hair is flattering here; we’re
talking about whether he raped someone.
Any discussion of the allegations should take into account their
seriousness. But the articles Drama Fever has chosen to reblog, in
combination with their packaging of them, do anything but.
Their blog’s coverage of the case has primarily involved breathless
finger-pointing, reporting hearsay sources as fact, and positioning
it as just another silly fandom rift. Its has been full of reporters
“re-enacting” the scene (aka, going to the bar in question and
drinking soju)
and interviews with “friends” of the people involved (alleged
victim A’s alleged friend B, to be specific).
For a few memorable days early on in the story, they even posted a
poll where readers could weigh in with their opinion on Park Shi
Hoo’s guilt or innocence. Once blood was in the water, accusations
of other crimes began to appear, ranging from fan exploitation to
financial improprieties.
And I’m sure someone was pleased
with him- or herself for coming up with cheeky a headline that played on the title of Park Shi Hoo’s most recent drama, but that doesn’t mean they should have used it. (“Cheongdamdong Malice,” in case you were wondering.)
That’s malicious, all right. |
Ultimately, though, I’m unconvinced that we can really blame international news
sites like Drama Fever for the deplorable coverage
this story has received. In the vast majority of cases, they’re only
translating what has been published in the Korean press. And while it seems
particularly egregious this coverage isn’t all that different
from what you might read in an American source like People
magazine. If a similar case
happened with an A-list American actor, you can be sure our
entertainment news would also be full of interviews with the
accused’s second grade teacher, drugstore cashier, and childhood
next door neighbor. (“According to sources close to Beyonce...”) But People would
include these things in the context of a larger, fact-based article,
which would take some of the sting off the ridiculous nature of their sources.
No
matter their home country, Internet news sites have been wringing as
much drama from this case as they can possibly manage. CJ E&MenewsWorld even posted a vaguely accusatory article noting that Park
Shi Hoo had been using a fake birth year so he would seem younger. At
the bottom of the article, they add: “It became that (sic) Park Si Hoo
was recently sued for rape by an aspiring celebrity on February 18.
Park Si Hoo has denied all charges.”
While unwritten, the presumed relationship between these two issues
is fairly clear: wouldn’t someone who would lie about his age also
lie about other things?
An
article on Chosunilbo blunders into a similar problem: after an
initial paragraph stating the facts of the case as they’re known, it wanders off to discuss a number of similar “alleged”
incidents. The article closes by saying: “But police warned of the
pitfalls facing aspiring entertainers. They tend to be wary when
approaching agents, who have a reputation for being predatory and
little better than pimps, ‘but they tend to let their guard down
when they meet a star,’ according to one police officer.” This article seems awfully prejudiced against Park Shi Hoo, the “star” in this scenario.
Not
that Park Shi Hoo is the only one being maligned by the press.
Hancinema, apparently quoting from a Korean-language article posted
at segye.com, provides a quote from the owner of the bar where Park Shi Hoo and the alleged victim met. “I wasn’t there
at that moment to see it but I asked around my workers and looked at
the CCTV. ‘A’ didn’t seem as drunk as she says she was. She got
up from her seat and walked on her own and Park only escorted her in
case she fell. She walked down the flight of stair without a
problem.” That may be true, but the problems with this comment are still legion: this is a man who
makes money off Park Shi Hoo’s patronage, and presumably the
patronage of other stars. He could be putting his livelihood at risk
if he said pretty much anything else. The only reason for interviewing him in the first place is opportunistic journalism: all he has to offer is a tangental relationship to the case and a subjective opinion formed by watching a video that
was probably taken at a lousy resolution and likely included no
sound.
Citing
an article posted at Sportseoul.com, a Dramafever post dated February
21 is titled “‘Why me?’ Netizens Attack Uninvolved Woman in Park Shi Hoo Case.” It turns out that the accuser’s name has been
leaked in Korea (thankfully, I think we English-language
speakers have been spared this detail), leading to reprisals against
an unrelated woman with the same name. “On the 19th ‘B’s’
picture, full name, university, and major spread rapidly throughout
the online community and social networking sites. Netizens pinpointed
‘B’ as the one pressing charges in the Park Shi Hoo case.
Derogatory comments such as ‘She seems to be desperate to become a
celebrity,’ ‘gold digger,’ ‘Don’t use Park Shi Hoo’
poured throughout the internet.” The article fairly accurately uses
the phrase “witch hunt” to describe this turn of events.
And
how about those “netizens”? Just like you and me, they have no
particular knowledge or insight. Yet they’re quoted time and again in articles about this case (and, in fact, in most reporting about K-ent). Since when did the opinions of people utterly unrelated to
the news of the day matter? You can find an idiot who will say
anything on the Internet. (See?) Suffice it to say that there have been many
disparaging comments about the accuser on various sites, and some of
them have been reposted so often they’ve practically become memes.
We’ve
got plenty of other things to think about on the character
assassination front. A statement from Park Shi Hoo’s lawyer posted
on Chosun.com and picked up by Drama Fever is just as guilty of
attacking the (alleged) victim as any netizen comment. “While
Trainee A claims to have been unconscious inside Park’s home for 13
hours, her recollection of even the smallest details that
coincidentally work against Park should question her credibility....
Her actions to present have been questionable.” It may be part of
his job to cast doubt on the accuser’s case, but shouldn’t he be
saving it for the courtroom? I also suspect he’s been watching too
much television. We’re talking about passing out from the use of
controlled substances here, not drama-style
amnesia.
“I sure look guilty, don’t I? That’s because I am, at least according to the script of the movie this image was taken from.” |
It’s
also worth considering the image choices news sources have been
making when posting information about this case. On this front,
bloggers and the news media are damned by one of our readers’
expectations: every post needs a picture. It’s one thing to
include file images of Park Shi Hoo at press conferences or other events with articles covering
the case, but I’ve seen several sites that have used promotional
stills from his work—including a menacing shot from a recent movie
in which he played a serial killer, as seen in the above screen grab from
Korean-language new site Newsmon. When the news was first being
reported, the featured images tended to be just another opportunity to
show cute Park Shi Hoo being cute. But Chosunilbro took another
approach: their first article on the topic shows the accused making a
Homer Simpson–style “D’oh, who me?” face. (See the top of this post.) As professional organizations, these sources
should know better. The photos they choose to represent a story are
just as important as the words.
I’m
not sure that I like the alternative approach much better: utter
silence. I respect sites like Dramabeans and Couch Kimchi for not
covering this story at all. But the
coverage of and responses to these accusations tell me an awful lot about
life in Korea, which is a subject I’m interested in. I wouldn’t want a news site to be filtering and pre-treating
Korean articles to jibe with my American sensibilities—that’s
tantamount to translating “oppa” as “boy” in subtitles meant
for an international audience. We’re smart people and able to
critically assess the information, so why should a
news site act as my nanny by not reporting the news as it’s
consumed in Korea?
***
After
I got over my initial shock at the allegations against Park Shi Hoo,
I started thinking about the website Parksihoo4U. The people who
created it care so much about this actor—both his work and his
management-approved public persona as a clean-living, regular
guy—that they built a website and community around him. So how do
they deal with his alleged involvement in a rape case?
I'd like to think what they’re doing isn’t blindly accepting that Park Shi Hoo is
innocent, just because he’s good-looking and famous. And they also
shouldn’t be accepting that he’s guilty. His trial and conviction
in the court of public opinion is just as much a miscarriage of
justice as it would be if he really did commit rape and wasn’t
punished for it.
The
fan/idol relationship can be a weird, complicated thing. We identify
with our chosen stars and rest some tiny corner of our identity on
our relationship to them. The things I love are part of what makes me
me— being
a Kdrama fan is in my blood, just as it’s in other people’s blood
to support Lance Armstrong or write Star
Wars fanfiction. The
lovely screenplay of the American movie Adaptation
put
it best: You are what you love, not what loves you.
When
the objects of our love betray us—by being involved with doping or
making a crappy set of prequels—it hurts, just as it would if
someone we actually knew had betrayed us. And what happens when a
beloved celebrity commits a terrible crime, like rape? We can still
enjoy his roles, but what does that mean for our (utterly internal)
connection with him as a human being?
I
can’t help but feel that fandom is a bit of a sacred covenant. We
support a celebrity’s creative endeavors and enable them to do what
they do. This doesn’t mean we have any right to stalk them or nose
into their private lives or demand that they remain celibate forever,
trapped like butterflies pinned under glass. I think it is fair for
us to ask one thing of our chosen stars, though: Don’t be a creep.
And when our celebrity’s end of the deal isn’t upheld, our hearts
are collateral damage.
There
is and should be a barrier between the personal and professional
lives of stars. Although I’m not innocent of crossing the line
myself, I appreciate that we shouldn’t expect our stars to live for
us any more than we should be living for them. Korea’s over-the-top
saseng (personal
life) fanhood isn’t something that’s good for anyone. But having
a public persona is part and parcel of celebrity, and while Park Shi
Hoo never asked anyone to create a website in his honor, he
benefitted from it and from the adoration of his fans.
The only people who know what really happened that night are the ones
who were involved—not you, not me, not whatever bottom-feeder the
press is interviewing on the subject today. In a case like this, it’s
possible that no one else will ever know; rape is hard to prove. Without a confession or concrete evidence, it all comes
down to he-said, she-said.
There’s
talk about television stations around the world backing out of airing Cheongdamdong Alice, all because of the unproven
allegations against its star. His image has been so thoroughly
tainted by the scandal that I’m not sure it could ever recover.
Whatever its outcome, this news about Park Shi Hoo just makes me incredibly sad. Sad that there are people who rape, sad that there are people who lie, and sad that it’s so hard to tell what’s true. No matter what, an innocent person’s life is going to be forever changed—whether that person is an unjustly accused Park Shi Hoo or a faceless girl who was horribly taken advantage of by someone our society led her to admire.
And then there are the fans, we who so readily hand our hearts over to complete strangers and hope for the best. Either way, our loss is a sad one, too.
Whatever its outcome, this news about Park Shi Hoo just makes me incredibly sad. Sad that there are people who rape, sad that there are people who lie, and sad that it’s so hard to tell what’s true. No matter what, an innocent person’s life is going to be forever changed—whether that person is an unjustly accused Park Shi Hoo or a faceless girl who was horribly taken advantage of by someone our society led her to admire.
And then there are the fans, we who so readily hand our hearts over to complete strangers and hope for the best. Either way, our loss is a sad one, too.
Amanda, I too am saddened by all this. In this day of papparazi and willing to do anything for a buck or 15 minutes of fame, even more sadly, it will only get worse.
ReplyDeleteIndeed. And I worry what this means for morality clauses in contracts. On the flip side of this incident is the Japanese girl-group member who shaved her head after getting caught dating a boy. All this flap about Park Shi Hoo is probably going to make the morality pendulum swing ever-further toward the puritanical, in spite of the special circumstances. This is rape, not a secret marriage between a dreamy young actor and "Korea's little sister." But it's also just another example of a star's personal life being dangerous to his image.
DeleteGreat post. It's true that the reports out there are really varied and lots of them are based purely on hearsay.
ReplyDeleteIf you haven't checked out Koala's Playground for updates, you might be interested to do so.. She's a lawyer by profession, so her posts on the case are not only fair, but informed from a legal perspective.
Thanks for the tip! I hadn't been aware of Koala's profession, but I've been trying to keep up with her coverage of this story. Everything she has to say is totally sensible. I actually think a number of personal bloggers are taking a more balanced approach to this story than the press :b
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteLiving in Seoul, I've witnessed a few occasions similar to ParkShiHoo's case. She/He got convicted due to substance abuse or tax evasion or anything, then proven to be innocent. However, in the mean time, the individual's reputation has already fallen to the ground. Who will pay back her/his life? Why those seemingly innocent people is so mean against a few targeted individuals? I just hope everyone keeps one thing in mind; no one is guilty until the verdict.
ReplyDeleteUnfortunately I think this sort of thing happens everywhere. The general public decides that someone is guilty for whatever reason, and they stick with that opinion whatever happens. It's also sort of like the reporting of the American school shootings at Columbine in the 1990s—all these "facts" that were initially reported were eventually disproven, but they're still part of our national myth about the tragedy. The perpetrators’ guilt was never in question, but lots of other things were.
DeleteOh my gosh! This is one of the best, most literate, honest, intelligent blog post I've ever read. You brought in so many topics and sub-topics of this Park Shi Hoo issue and addressed them honestly and in a manner that was fair to both sides. Also, your comments about the dramafever blog were not mean-spirited but honest. And not at all self-rigtheous. I've always loved your blog but this post just totally ramped my love up to a whole nother level. Thanks.
ReplyDeleteThanks for the kind words! I took a number of journalism classes when I was in school, which has made it painful for me to watch this three-ring circus develop around Park Shi Hoo. I'm still not sure if different approaches to journalism in the west and east play into the horrible nature of the coverage, or if all we're seeing is the worst that Korea's entertainment press has to offer. I just hope a final conclusion is reached soon, because the articles get worse and worse every passing day.
DeleteI've been watching the coverage with my eyes half-closed, afraid I'll see something that will either damn PSH forever or cause me to want to rage - either with the possible injustice of false accusations, or the idiocy of news 'sources' themselves. I appreciate your willingness to talk of the matter, and in such an intellent fashion.
ReplyDeleteThis has been kind of a train wreck for me--I don't want to look, but I can't tear my eyes away.
Delete(Is it too shallow of me to admit that I wish this could have happened *after* I'd watched all of Park Shi Hoo's dramas, so I could still enjoy them? It's going to be hard to see him the same way.)
I'm pretty sure there are a lot of people out there who are going to find it hard to look at him the same way. Guilty or not. Insightful blog post btw, couldn't have said it better myself!
DeleteThank you, Amanda, for sharing. If I had wanted to write about this case (I have decided I will not), I wish I would have written it as well as you have (is that even an English sentece?!)
ReplyDeletePersonally, I was deeply troubled, even shaken by this news. But gradually, I have become really disgusted with it all (and I mean IT ALL, the potential deed, the potential lie, the media, the fans, the comments on the various blogs I'm following) that I no longer really (want to) care (though I also am sad about it). This is not my world. This is not related to me or the life I am leading. I may have liked PSH (as an actor) in the past, but my goodness, I am a mature woman who is fully capable of distinguishing between the image of an actor that I like and his "true" personality. We do not often have to actually think about the second - but if we are confronted with it, well ... let's not be too surprised that these people are people like everybody else, or maybe even criminals.
Therefore, I am trying to remain as neutral as I can and just hope, sincerely, that it is at all possible to provide justice in this messy, messy case.
I completely agree about everything you said. I was surprised how upset I was about the news—I'm a grownup who should know better than to believe what I see on television. But it still feels awful to realize that someone I've invited into my mind could have done something like this. It also doesn't help that this is my first big scandal about a Korean celebrity. The news coverage is like watching a tennis game: "He's totally innocent!"—"He's a rapist!"—"Just kidding, she's a gold digger!"—"He even drugged her!"
DeleteI hope justice is served, but it's hard to imagine how it could be, barring real, conclusive evidence—not somebody's text messages :b
I just read that Park Shi Hoo's mother met with the accuser's father the day after the alledged incident and has also met with her lawyer. If true, then it is certainly an example of what Korean mothers are like. And I thought in K-Dramas it was exaggerated. I guess not!!
ReplyDeleteJust found your blog. I know that this case is over but wanted to tell you that your article is like a breath of fresh air after having read the news on this case. I followed the different blogs listed on this page and just want you to know that your article is the most clear headed and adult of them all. I have added your blog to my favorites and look forward to reading more of your article. Thank you for sharing your thoughts.
ReplyDeleteI'm not his fan and will never be the ones, i'm just a big fan of his drama Family Honor.
ReplyDeleteI've followed PSH case from the beginning and really want to know the final verdict because this is serious allegations, sexual assault not just a simple one night stand as many of his fans acclaimed. But in the end what i got just the biggest disappointment. We'll never know the truth and i really hate on how this case disclosed, just too easy and simple like that??? The two dropped all cases ??? Really really frustating...