Painter of the Wind: A-
I sometimes revisit Coffee Prince’s online
reviews just to vicariously relive the wonder of seeing this Kdrama
for the first time. They tend to full of fawning adoration, but I recently
found something unexpected: homophobia. “A fine romantic comedy,” the reviewer wrote, “with a backhanded endorsement of homosexual love.”
I think it’s safe to say that most Americans of my
generation or younger don’t think that gayness is a big deal, the general
consensus being that as long as consenting adults are involved, it’s not
society’s business whom I—or anyone else—chooses to love. It seems that Korea’s
views on homosexuality are more traditional, though, and that in Korea the show Coffee
Prince really is notable for its approach
to same-sex relationships.
As far as I’m concerned, Coffee Prince is not a show about homosexuality. It’s a show that
references homosexuality, sure, and uses it as a convenient obstacle
to draw out the romantic tension between its two leads. There isn’t one minute, however,
when the viewer believes they’re watching two people of the same gender fall in
love. We see Eun Chan as a girl from the very beginning, even if Han Gyul
doesn’t.
It’s a whole different story in The Painter of the Wind, a similarly themed drama that aired in 2008. Sungkyunkwan
Scandal’s less candy-coated and candy-colored cousin, it revolves around the misadventures of Shin Yoon Bok, a
Joseon-era girl pretending to be a boy in order to attend the royal painting
institute. Naturally, she falls in love with her dashing, nonconformist (male)
teacher and the two work together to solve the mystery of her father’s murder.
Thoughtful, girl-centered sageuks are hard to find, but Painter of the Wind is both. Its speedy plotting and fully drawn characters are a pleasure to watch, making it hard to stop at just one (or five) episodes at a sitting. And, unexpectedly, its painting scenes are every bit as visceral and exhilarating as the most well-executed action sequences you can imagine.
Thoughtful, girl-centered sageuks are hard to find, but Painter of the Wind is both. Its speedy plotting and fully drawn characters are a pleasure to watch, making it hard to stop at just one (or five) episodes at a sitting. And, unexpectedly, its painting scenes are every bit as visceral and exhilarating as the most well-executed action sequences you can imagine.
What I find most noteworthy here isn’t the show's main relationship, though. The low-key, courtly love Yoon
Bok shares with her mentor is sweet and touching, if unremarkable and vaguely
incestuous (he’s much older and was close friends with her real father). It's Painter of the Wind's secondary couple that really caught my attention: Yoon Bok and Jeong Hyang, the gayageum-playing gisaeng. (Try saying that five times fast. Or once, even.) While disguised as a boy, Yoon Bok allows her powerful friendship with this girl to veer into love. Their relationship is so intense, in fact, that even after the big reveal of Yoon Bok's gender, the couple continues to call each other "beautiful beloved."
Yoon Bok’s family are the only ones who know that she’s a
woman, and as that family begins to shatter she is left almost totally without
a support system. The show stresses that in Jeong Hyang, Yoon Bok sees both
herself—a young artist forced into servitude, her life not her own—and what Yoon Bok believes she could never be again, a mannerly, feminine woman.
As Jeong Hyang becomes Yoon Bok’s
muse and their relationship deepens, they share a number of tender, loving
scenes and enjoy some degree of physical intimacy. We’re not talking Boys
Don’t Cry here, but at one point Jeong
Hyang is clearly ready to go all the way with her dear painter, and Yoon Bok is just as clearly
reluctant to stop the proceedings.
When she’s near her male mentor
Yoon Bok is nervous and jumpy, afraid to touch him and more than willing to
stay in the role of subservient, malleable student. With Jeong Hyang, however,
she isn’t a bit shy and thoughtlessly takes the lead, right down to convincing
the gisaeng to pose half-naked for a painting.
The script doesn’t seem to take a
stand on what these differences mean—maybe Yoon Bok’s easy comfort around Jeong
Hyang is meant to show that Yoon Bok doesn’t view her in a romantic light. Or
maybe the parallel relationships exist to show Yoon Bok’s duality. She has been
living as a man for her whole adolescence, forced into the role by an adoptive
father hungry for her skill as a painter, and has almost completely lost her
female self. Half male, she takes the lead. Half female, she is led.
If you squint just right, it's even possible to find a happy ending for Yoon Bok and Jeong Hyang. As foreshadowed in the drama's first episode, the main couple don't end up together. But the show says goodbye to both girls in the same way—they're shown separately boarding what appears to be the very same ship, headed off into the very same horizon.
If you squint just right, it's even possible to find a happy ending for Yoon Bok and Jeong Hyang. As foreshadowed in the drama's first episode, the main couple don't end up together. But the show says goodbye to both girls in the same way—they're shown separately boarding what appears to be the very same ship, headed off into the very same horizon.
In terms of OTP, Painter of the
Wind has left me no choice: Yoon Bok’s
mentor may be a father to her, but Jeong Hyang is her heart.
Wow, what a beautiful review. Thank you so much for this
ReplyDeleteI just finished it and I'm so happy she didn't end up married to Dan Won. Not that I think they didn't love each other because they clearly loved each other, but just because it would have been the easy way out.
ReplyDeleteMaybe also because the two girls have better chemistry than the main couple.
i think so too. I'd also like to think that they met after that(the two girls) and lived happily.
Deleteooh wow, first of all, i love you..! thank you!!
ReplyDeletethis is exactly what i search for painter of the wind couple-wise review. this is what i feel and think happen when watching the drama, but no review or article satisfied me yet until i read yours.
and thank you, for not branding this beautiful romance with lesbianism (not that i againts it, it's just not right)
no wonder they won best couple award ^^
Actually, I thought the love between the two girls, on Yok Bok part, was their connection as artists. Yok Bok recognized her not as a prostitute but as a gifted artist, and a gifted female artist just like her. So it is like Jeong is living the life that Yok Bok wants to live, openly as a woman and as an artist. However, the unveiling scene was just to show someone, Jeong, that she is really a girl, and she knows what Jeong is going through, they are kindred souls. not that it was hot and intense but i think there is another layer there about the plight of women as artist and not as lovers/mothers/wives. Yok Bok is in disguise, and Jeong is considered an object for sex...
ReplyDeletewhere can i find full movie .. i cant watch because of my country ..
ReplyDeletewhere can i find full movie .. i cant watch because of my country ..
ReplyDeleteYou can use the Hola extension on Chrome and watch it on Viki.com. That's how I did it.
DeleteOh my god, does the artist and the musician get together?
ReplyDeleteI'm so friggin' happy. Will continue watching now.
Unfortunately yet fortunately, I was able to watch this beautiful Korean historical fiction 9 years after it was shown. The review was indeed nice and I hope there came a time when Yoon Bok had settled for what she believed is her real identity. Either with her mentor or with her beloved Jeong Hyang, I am sure Yoon Bok would have found real happines at long last.
ReplyDeleteThank you for good and useful comments.
ReplyDeleteSa gaming สมัคร
Me encanto tu reseña y para mi el final es como un nuevo comienzo
ReplyDelete2021..inlove with this pair.. I love your review.
ReplyDeleteIn 2021. Amazing that after more than 10 years, this beautiful review tells what is on my mind (nice comments as well).
ReplyDeleteIndeed, the two girls' storyline is the most charming part. I enjoy the way the two actresses put it-- Low-key, intense and artistic. The director left an open end for our imagination. I believe Yoon Bok took a boat to find Jeong Hyang and they finally lived in a reclusive way.
BTW, in the novel, Hyang was completely naked for Yoon to paint on the second time they met. So instead of turning friendship into love, I suppose their mutual admiration as two talented females starts straightforward at the beginning and there is absolutely no friendship at all LOL. (Which is more attractive than the TV series).
I'm 4 episodes in and hate to stop watching for work and sleep. I watched another brilliant movie about a Joseon female painter that posed as a man to pursue her craft. How sad women could be talented but couldn't attend schools for their craft like men could.
ReplyDelete